Number 1
Number 2
Number 3
Number 4
Number 5
Number 6
In Memorium
Bruce B Smith
1917-2007
Bruce Brownfield Smith was born on December 16, 1917, in Seattle, WA, of a pioneer family. He passed away on October 28, 2007 after a brief illness. Bruce was preceded in death by his wife Lola and is survived by daughters Joy and Nicki Smith. Dr Smith will be greatly missed on both a professional and personal level by all who knew him; however, his contributions to the profession will live on and, hopefully, serve as an inspiration to new generations of dentists.
Editorial
Visions of the Past and the Future
Letter
from Dr Andy McKibbib, President, American Academy of Gold Foil Operators
History
A History of the Academy of Gold Foil Operators, Chapter II
Clinical Research
Clinical Relevance:
For two years, the three restoration/adhesive combinations used in this study (Dyract AP/Prime & Bond NT with NRC pretreatment, Dyract AP/Prime & Bond NT with phosphoric acid pretreatment and Filtek A110/Single Bond) exhibited very good clinical performance in Class III cavities. Clinically simplified systems and handling characteristics of materials may effect their clinical performance.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the 24-month clinical performance of a microfilled composite using a one-bottle bonding system and a compomer that uses one-bottle bonding systems, which include a non-rinse conditioner or 36% phosphoric acid gel in Class III cavities.
Each patient received three restorations due to primary caries of the anterior teeth, resulting in a total of 96 restorations. Three types of restoration/adhesive combinations were used: a microfilled resin composite (Filtek A110) with a one-bottle bonding system (Single Bond); a polyacid-modified resin composite (compomer) (Dyract AP) with a filled one-bottle bonding system (Prime & Bond NT) using 36% phosphoric acid pretreatment and a polyacid-modified resin composite (compomer) (Dyract AP) with a filled one-bottle bonding system (Prime & Bond NT) using a non-rinse conditioner (NRC) and a self-priming pretreatment. At baseline and one- and two-year recalls, color match, marginal discoloration, wear or loss of anatomical form, caries, marginal adaptation and surface texture of the restorations were evaluated by two experienced, calibrated examiners using the modified Ryge criteria.
After two years, one restoration from each group had a rating of Charlie (C) for both color match and marginal discoloration and needed to be replaced. Therefore, the failure rate was 3.6% (success rate: 96.4%) for each group at the end of two years. Statistical analysis showed no significant differences among the three groups in color match, marginal discoloration, wear or loss of anatomical form, marginal adaptation and surface texture after two years. Also, no statistically significant differences were determined for each group with respect to color match, marginal discoloration, wear or loss of anatomical form, marginal adaptation and surface texture at the end of two years.
Clinical Relevance:
The use of light-activation sources did not affect the outcome of in-office bleaching with 35% hydrogen peroxide.
SUMMARY:
This study clinically evaluated the alteration of color, color stability, dental sensitivity and gingival irritation on patients undergoing dental bleaching using varying bleaching methods and light-activation sources. According to pre-established criteria, 40 patients were selected and randomly divided into four groups (n=10): Group 1-35% Hydrogen Peroxide (HP); Group 2-35% HP plus Halogen Curing Light XL 3000 (3M/ESPE); Group 3-35% HP plus Demetron LED (Kerr) and Group 4-35% HP plus LED/LASER Curing Units (Bio-art). For all groups, there were two sessions of bleaching with 35% HP, with a one week break between sessions. At each bleaching session, three applications of the bleaching gel were used. Two methods of shade evaluation were performed before and after the first week, second week, first month and after six months of the bleaching treatment. These methods were VITA Easyshade Spectrophotometer and Vita Classical Shade Guide. Statistical analysis using ANOVA demonstrated equality between the participating groups when evaluating the group and time variables. The In-Office dental bleaching treatments of vital teeth with 35% HP did not prove to be more effective when light sources were used. There was no difference in color stability between groups until the sixth month of evaluation.
Laboratory Research
Cytotoxicity of Composite Materials Polymerized with LED Curing Units
Clinical Relevance:
Curing light intensity is one of the main parameters for proper resin composite cure. Inadequate polymerization of a composite can be harmful to vital pulp tissue and can compromise the durability and quality of the final restoration.
SUMMARY:
The proper intensity and illumination time of a curing light is of great importance for the complete polymerization of resin composites and long-lasting resin composite restorations. Inadequately cured resin composites can have a cytotoxic effect on pulp tissue by releasing unreacted monomers. This study determined whether there is any difference in cytotoxicity between composite materials illuminated with different curing modes of LED curing units. Thin layers of two composite materials were polymerized using three different modes of the Bluephase C8 LED curing unit: a high intensity mode (HIP-800 mW/cm2, 20 seconds), a soft-start mode (SOF-650 mW/cm2 first 5 seconds, 800 mW/cm2 next 25 seconds) and a low intensity mode (LOP-650 mW/cm2, 30 seconds). Lymphocyte cultures were treated with both polymerized and unpolymerized composites using one of the modes stated above. Cells were analyzed using the trypan blue exclusion test, the acridine orange/ethidium bromide dying technique and an alkaline comet assay. Significant cytotoxicity was observed for 120 mg of unpolymerized composites and those polymerized with the HIP polymerization mode. A significant level of DNA damage was detected for 120 mg of unpolymerized composites. However, curing via the LOP program exhibited the lowest genotoxicity. Longer curing time with lower intensity results in less cytotoxicity than shorter curing exposure using a higher intensity of light emitted from the curing light source.
Leakage Pathway of Class V Cavities Restored With Different Flowable Resin Composite Restorations
Clinical Relevance:
The flowable resins evaluated in this study showed leakage patterns (micro and nano), indicating that the bonding system used did not achieve perfect sealing at the restortion/dentin interface.
SUMMARY:
This study investigated the leakage pathway of facial and lingual Class V cavities restored with different flowable resin composites bonded with one bonding agent by examining the resin/dentin interface. Forty Class V cavities were etched with 37% phosphoric acid gel; Single Bond dental adhesive was applied, then the cavities were randomly divided into four groups (n=10). Three groups were restored with one of three flowable resin composites (Grandio Flow, Filtek Flow and Admira Flow). The fourth group was restored with Z250 (hybrid resin composite) to serve as a control. The specimens were then placed in 50% w/v silver nitrate solution for 24 hours and immersed in a photodeveloping solution for eight hours. Thereafter, the specimens were sectioned bucco-lingually, polished, mounted on stubs, gold sputter coated and examined by scanning electron microscope.
Silver particle penetration length with and without gap formation was measured directly on the scanning electron microscope monitor and calculated as a percentage of the total length of the cut dentin surface that was penetrated by silver nitrate. The data were analyzed with one-way ANOVA and Tukey HSD test. The groups restored with Filtek Flow and Admira Flow showed a microleakage pattern where silver nitrate penetration was observed with gap formation at the tooth/restoration interface and Filtek Flow recorded significantly higher leakage than Admira Flow. Grandio Flow showed similar marginal adaptation to Z250 resin composite with no gap formation at the interface. However, silver ions had penetrated beneath the resin-impregnated layer in cavities restored with Grandio Flow and Z250, indicating nanoleakage occurred. This study suggests that volumetric shrinkage in resin composites remains a problem. Although some new technologies are trying to solve the problem of composite shrinkage, the bonding system used in this study did not achieve perfect sealing at the restoration/dentin interface. This might affect durability of the bond to dentin.
Clinical Relevance:
Beveling of the cavosurface margin can improve resistance to fracture and the marginal adaptation of posterior composite restorations, reducing the deleterious effect of storage with thermal cycling on restoration quality. Generally, indirect restorations showed similar performance compared to direct restorations.
SUMMARY:
This in vitro study evaluated the effect of technique, use of a bevel and thermal cycling on the fracture resistance and gap formation of resin composite MOD restorations. Fracture resistance was measured on standard MOD cavities prepared in 100 upper premolars that were stored for 24 hours and 6 months with 1000 thermal cycles. Subgroups (n=10) were beveled or non-beveled preparations and direct restorations (Adper Single Bond/Filtek Z250) and indirect restorations (prepolymerized Filtek Z250 cemented with Rely X ARC). Ten sound teeth and 10 specimens with MOD preparations without restorations served as the positive and negative controls, respectively. The specimens were subjected to axial compression in a universal testing machine at a crosshead speed of 0.5 mm/minute. Failure patterns were analyzed by stereomicroscopy (40x). To evaluate gap presence or absence, proximal box cavities were prepared in 24 human third molars that were restored as described above. The specimens were evaluated under SEM examination after 24 hours and six months. Data were statistically analyzed by ANOVA and multiple comparison tests at the 0.05 level of significance. After 24 hours, the beveled restorations exhibited higher fracture strength values than the non-beveled restorations, and all groups showed resistance similar or superior to sound teeth. After six months, the highest fracture resistance was obtained for beveled inlays and the lowest values were observed for direct restorations with butt joints. Thermal cycling decreased fracture resistance in the majority of the groups. The main fracture pattern observed was cohesive failure in the material, but adhesive failures increased over time, especially in the non-beveled restorations. Under SEM examination, no difference was observed among the groups after 24 hours. However, after six months, the beveled restorations exhibited no gap formation. It was concluded that storage with thermal cycling decreased fracture resistance, bevels improved fracture resistance and, in general, indirect restorations were not superior to direct restorations.
Clinical Relevance:
One-step polishing systems exhibited similar or better surface roughness values when compared to multi-step polishing systems. In all groups, mylar-strip created surfaces showed lower microhardness values than polished surfaces. Different polishing procedures did not effect the microhardness of nanocomposites. One-step polishing systems may be a good choice for polishing nanocomposites, resulting in reduced chair time.
SUMMARY:
Objectives: This in vitro study evaluated the surface roughness and microhardness of nanocomposites that contain nanoparticles and a microhybrid composite finished and polished with two different one-step polishing systems and a conventional multi-step polishing system.
Methods and Materials: The materials evaluated were Filtek Supreme XT, Grandio, Ceram X, Aelite Aesthetic Enamel, Tetric EvoCeram and Filtek Z250. A total of 240 specimens (10-mm in diameter, 2 mm thick) were fabricated for both tests (n=120 each test) in a plexiglass mold covered with a Mylar strip. After polymerization, five specimens per group received no polishing treatment and served as the control for both tests. For each composite group (n=15), the specimens were randomly divided into three polishing systems: PoGo, OptraPol and Sof-Lex. All polishing systems were applied according to the manufacturers' instructions after being ground wet with 1200 grid silicon carbide paper. The surface roughness values were determined using a profilometer. The microhardness measurements were performed using a digital microhardness tester (load 500 g; dwell time 15 seconds). The data were analyzed using the one-way ANOVA test at a significance level of 0.05 for both tests. Multiple comparison was performed with the Duncan Multiple Range test.
Results: The smoothest surfaces were achieved under Mylar strips in all composite groups (p<0.05). There were no statistically significant differences between polishing systems in the Filtek Supreme XT, Ceram X, Aelite Aesthetic Enamel and Grandio groups for surface roughness (p>0.05). In the Tetric EvoCeram group, Sof-Lex exhibited the highest roughness values. No statistically significant differences were evaluated between polishing systems (p>0.05); whereas, the surfaces under Mylar Strip showed statistically significant lower values than the polished surfaces in terms of microhardness (p<0.05).
Conclusion: One-step polishing systems may be successfully used for polishing nanocomposites.
Adhesion to Er:YAG Laser-prepared Dentin After Long-term Water Storage and Thermocycling
Clinical Relevance:
Simulation of thermal stress and long-term degradation presented in the oral environment adversely affected the adhesion of an etch & rinse adhesive system to Er:YAG laser-irradiated dentin.
SUMMARY:
This in vitro study evaluated the microtensile bond strength of a resin composite to Er:YAG-prepared dentin after long-term storage and thermocycling. Eighty bovine incisors were selected and their roots removed. The crowns were ground to expose superficial dentin. The samples were randomly divided according to cavity preparation method (I-Er:YAG laser and II-carbide bur). Subsequently, an etch & rinse adhesive system was applied and the samples were restored with a resin composite. The samples were subdivided according to time of water storage (WS)/number of thermocycles (TC) performed: A) 24 hours WS/no TC; B) 7 days WS/500 TC; C) 1 month WS/2,000 TC; D) 6 months WS/12,000 TC. The teeth were sectioned in sticks with a cross-sectional area of 1.0-mm2, which were loaded in tension in a universal testing machine. The data were subjected to two-way ANOVA, Scheffe and Fisher's tests at a 5% level. In general, the bur-prepared group displayed higher microtensile bond strength values than the laser-treated group. Based on one-month water storage and 2,000 thermocycles, the performance of the tested adhesive system to Er:YAG-laser irradiated dentin was negatively affected (Group IC), while adhesion of the bur-prepared group decreased only within six months of water storage combined with 12,000 thermocycles (Group IID). It may be concluded that adhesion to the Er:YAG laser cavity preparation was more affected by the methods used for simulating degradation of the adhesive interface.
Evaluation of the Cervical Integrity During Occlusal Loading of Class II Restorations
Clinical Relevance:
The periodical supervision of packable composite proximal restorations is necessary and essential, as microleakage greatly increases after axial mechanical load incidences, even when this material is associated with other materials, such as flowable composite, glass-ionomer or compomer.
SUMMARY:
There are many concerns regarding the clinical behavior of packable composite restorations in Class II cavities, particularly when those restorations are subjected to axial mechanical loads. This study evaluated microleakage in vitro in proximal vertical "slot"-type cavities with walls located in enamel and dentin, filled with packable composite, associated or not associated with a flowable composite, a reinforced light-curing glass-ionomer or a compomer, after being submitted to occlusal load cycling. These preparations were subjected to either occlusal load cycling or no occlusal load cycling.
Eighty human molars with enamel and dentin margins were treated with standardized cavity preparations (proximal vertical "slot" preparations). After completing the filling process using a packable composite (Filtek P60) with or without a cervical increment of flowable composite (Filtek flow), light-curing glass-ionomer (Vitremer) or compomer (Dyract AP), the molars were separated into two groups: control (without occlusal loading) and test, in which 4,000 one-second cycles of 150 N occlusal loading were applied. All 80 teeth were submitted to a microleakage test, then evaluated utilizing silver nitrate dye penetration. Significant statistical differences (Wilcoxon test, p<0.05) in the amount of leakage in enamel and dentin were found in both the control and test groups. After a paired comparison of the control and test groups, a significant statistical difference was found at the enamel level (Mann-Whitney test, p<0.05). In dentin, the only statistically significant difference found was the relation to the flow material. The Kruskal-Wallis test did not detect any statistically significant difference in the amount of leakage among the four materials studied, with a 5% level of significance for both enamel and dentin. Based on this data, it was concluded that restorations with margins located in dentin had greater microleakage than those restorations with margins located in enamel. When the samples were submitted to occlusal loading, they were negatively influenced, which increased microleakage values in enamel and dentin. There was no statistically significant difference among the four tested materials, when comparing their performance.
Clinical Relevance:
The application of antibacterial varnish affects the shear bond strength of tooth-colored restorative materials after six months.
SUMMARY:
This study investigated the effect of certain varnishes on the bond strength of different tooth-colored restorative materials applied to root dentin. One-hundred and eighty tooth slabs, including mesial and distal surfaces, were attained through dividing the teeth, then embedding them in methylmethacrylate. The root surfaces were ground flat through cementum, exposing the dentin. The samples were then randomly divided into three main groups: Group 1: Cervitec; Group 2: Fluor Protector and Group 3: No applications (control). Cervitec and Fluor Protector were applied to the root dentin surfaces according to the manufacturer's instructions. All the samples were kept in artificial saliva for six months. Each main group was subdivided into five groups of 12 teeth each: Group A: Flowable Resin Composite (Grandio Flow); Group B: Microhybrid Resin Composite (Artemis); Group C: Polyacid Modified Resin Composite (Dyract Extra); Group D: Resin Modified Glass Ionomer Cement (Vitremer) and Group E: Conventional Glass-Ionomer Cement (Ionofil Molar). Restorative materials were applied to the root dentin surfaces using a cylindrical mold. After thermocycling (1000 cycles, 5?C/55?C, dwell time 30 seconds), the shear bond strength of the restored samples was determined by a universal testing machine (Zwick Test Machine, Zwick GmbH & Co, Ulm, Germany) at a 5 mm/minute crosshead speed. Failure mode was determined under a stereomicroscope. The data were evaluated statistically by using one-way Analysis of Variance and Duncan tests (p?0.05). In the fluoride varnish group, all of the restorative materials except for Ionofil Molar, showed lower bond strengths when compared to the control group (p<0.05). In the Cervitec group, Artemis and Dyract Extra showed lower bond strengths; whereas, Ionofil Molar showed a higher bond strength than the control group (p<0.05). The highest percentage of cohesive fracture was observed in Artemis and Dyract Extra in the control group.
Effect of Pre-heating Resin Composite on Restoration Microleakage
Clinical Relevance:
The results of this study indicate that preheating composites can improve adaptation of resin composites to tooth structure. This technique significantly reduced microleakage. However, delaying light curing of the preheated composite after placement appears to be counterproductive and diminishes the positive effects from the preheating treatment. Flowable liner was less effective than preheating the composite in reducing microleakage.
SUMMARY:
Improving the adaptation of resin composites during placement is necessary to increase durability and reduce microleakage. Flowable resin liners have been introduced to improve adaptation in composite restorations. In addition, a device that lowers the viscosity of regular dental composites has been introduced (Calset, AdDent Inc, Danbury, CT, USA). This device lowers the viscosity of composites by preheating them to 54.4?C, which should lead to improved adaptation. This study compared microleakage in Class II composite restorations prepared using: 1) preheated resin composite, 2) unheated composite and 3) a flowable liner followed by unheated composite. Class II cavities were prepared on the mesial and distal surfaces of extracted third molars. Ten preparations were restored with resin composite (Esthet-X, Dentsply, York, PA, USA) for each of the following four techniques: Control (Esthet-X with Prime & Bond NT, Dentsply), Flowable (f) (as Control but used Esthet-X Flow liner), Preheated (p) (as Control but with preheating composite to 54.4?C) and Delay (d) (as Preheated but followed by a 15-second delay before curing). The teeth were restored, finished, stored in distilled water for 24 hours, then thermocycled between water bath temperatures of 5?C and 55?C with a one-minute dwell time for 1000 cycles. Tooth apices were sealed with epoxy and varnish was applied to within 1 mm of the restoration margins. The teeth were placed in 0.5% basic fuschin dye for 24 hours, rinsed, then embedded in self-curing resin. The embedded teeth were sectioned mesio-distally with a slow-speed diamond saw, providing multiple sections per restoration. Microleakage was rated by two evaluators using a 0-4 ordinal scale at the occlusal and cervical margins of each restoration and light microscopy (40x). The data were analyzed with Kruskal-Wallis ANOVA and pairwise testing with the Sign test (?=0.05). No statistical differences were observed among materials at the occlusal margin. However, at the cervical margin, the preheated samples P showed statistically lower microleakage than the controls and all other treatments. The D samples showed higher microleakage than the P and F samples. Ranked sum scores for the cervical were D (4516), C (3974), F (2756) and P (1958). There was a statistically greater amount of leakage at the cervical margins compared to the occlusal p<0.05. Preheating the composite resulted in significantly less microleakage at the cervical margins compared to the flowable liner and control. Delaying light curing of the preheated composite for 15 seconds (D) was counterproductive and led to increased microleakage.
Durability of Enamel Bonding Using Two-step Self-etch Systems on Ground and Unground Enamel
Clinical Relevance:
The effect of surface preparation was adhesive-dependent. Improvements in resin-enamel bond strength after enamel preparation were observed only for AdheSE and Optibond Solo plus Self-Etch Primer. Among the self-etch systems, mild, self-etch Clearfil SE Bond showed the highest bond strength values. No degradation of resin-enamel bonds was observed after 12 months of water storage, regardless of the adhesive tested.
SUMMARY:
This study examined the early and long-term microtensile bond strengths (?TBS) and interfacial enamel gap formation (IGW) of two-step self-etch systems to unground and ground enamel. Resin composite (Filtek Z250) buildups were bonded to proximal enamel surfaces (unground, bur-cut or SiC-treated enamel) of third molars after the application of four self-etch adhesives: a mild (Clearfil SE Bond [SE]), two moderate (Optibond Solo Plus Self-Etch Primer [SO] and AdheSE [AD]) and a strong adhesive (Tyrian Self Priming Etchant + One Step Plus [TY]) and two etch-and-rinse adhesive systems (Single Bond [SB] and Scotchbond Multi-Purpose Plus [SBMP]). Ten tooth halves were assigned for each adhesive. After storage in water (24 hours/37?C), the bonded specimens were sectioned into beams (0.9 mm2) and subjected to ?TBS (0.5 mm/minute) or interfacial gap width measurement (stereomicroscope at 400x) either immediately (IM) or after 12 months (12M) of water storage. The data were analyzed by three-way repeated measures ANOVA and Tukey's test (?=0.05). No gap formation was observed in any experimental condition. The ?TBS in the Si-C paper and diamond bur groups were similar and greater than the unground group only for the moderate self-etch systems (SO and AD). No reductions in bond strength values were observed after 12 months of water storage, regardless of the adhesive evaluated.
Microtensile Dentin and Enamel Bond Strengths of Recent Self-etching Resins
Clinical Relevance:
Adhesives with self-etching primers, which were evaluated in this study, produced immediate dentin and enamel bond strengths equivalent to the etch-and-rinse product, although they produced less etching of the enamel surface than etching with phosphoric acid.
SUMMARY:
In this study, the microtensile bond strengths of resin composites to dentin and enamel produced by recently introduced self-etching resins were determined. Included were two adhesives with self-etching primers, Clearfil SE (Kuraray) and Peak SE (Ultradent), four self-etching adhesives, Optibond All-In-One (Kerr), Clearfil S3 (Kuraray), Adper Prompt L-Pop (3M ESPE) and iBond (Heraeus Kulzer) and, as a positive control, PQ1 (Ultradent), an etch-and-rinse adhesive. Each product was evaluated using the same hybrid resin composite, Z250 (3M ESPE). Testing was performed after 48 hours using a "non-trimming" microtensile test at a crosshead speed of 0.6 mm/minute. Sample size was five teeth per group, with the value for each tooth calculated by averaging the bond strengths of seven beams derived from it.
Mean values in MPa (SD) for dentin were: Clearfil SE 81.6 (3.5),a Peak SE 80.3 (9.9),a PQ1 73.4 (4.9),a,b Optibond All-In-One 64.4 (5.9),b Clearfil S3 62.5 (2.2),b,c iBond 51.0 (4.0)c and Prompt L-Pop 33.9 (6.4).d Mean values in MPa (SD) for enamel were: PQ1 55.6 (2.5),a Clearfil SE 54.1 (5.4),a Prompt L-Pop 54.0 (5.4),a Peak SE 51.8 (1.5),a,b Clearfil S3 44.3 (5.2),b,c Optibond All-In-One 40.1 (2.1)c,d and iBond 33.8 (3.3).d (Values for each substrate with the same letter were not significantly different, one-way ANOVA, Tukey-Kramer Multiple Comparison Test, p<0.05.) Compared to the positive control, PQ1, only adhesives with self-etching primers, Clearfil SE and Peak SE, were as effective in bonding to both enamel and dentin. With the exception of Prompt L-Pop, scanning electron micrographs of the etched enamel surface produced by self-etching products indicated far less surface topography than conventional etching, even for self-etching primer systems producing the same bond strengths as the etch-and-rinse adhesive.
Microleakage in Overflared Root Canals Restored with Different Fiber Reinforced Dowels
Clinical Relevance:
Based on the in vitro results of this study, restoration of a tooth with an overflared root canal, using individually shaped polyethylene reinforced dowels, may help to reduce microleakage.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated microleakage in overflared root canals restored with four different types of adhesively-luted fiber-reinforced dowels: DT Light Post (LP), Glassix (GL), Ribbond (RB) and StickTech Post (ST). Forty non-carious, single-rooted mandibular human premolars with straight root canals were prepared using a step-back technique and obturated with gutta-percha using lateral condensation. The restored roots were randomly divided into four groups (n=10). The root canals were overprepared, creating an overflared dowel space, and each dowel was adhesively luted using a total-etched adhesive (Single Bond) and dual-polymerizing luting agent (RelyX ARC). All specimens were thermal cycled 1000 times between 5?C and 55?C and stored in 2% methylene-blue solution for one week. The teeth were cut horizontally into three consecutive sections: apical (A), middle (M) and coronal (C). Each section was digitally photographed from the occlusal direction under a stereomicroscope. The images were transferred to a PC and stored in TIFF format. For each image, dye penetration was estimated as the ratio of methylene-blue-infiltrated surface divided by total dentin surfaces. The data were compared and statistically analyzed using the Kruskal-Wallis test (p<.05). The Mann-Whitney U test was used to compute multiple pairwise comparisons to determine differences between the experimental groups (p=.083). Dentin-luting agent fiber-reinforced dowel (FRD) interfaces were evaluated under a scanning electron microscope. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) showed detachment of the luting resin from the dentin surface in varying degrees in all specimens evaluated. All groups showed considerable leakage at the sections evaluated. Significant differences were demonstrated between LP-RB for the apical and middle sections and between GL-RB, LP-RB and ST-RB for the coronal sections (p<.0083). Among the FRDs evaluated, the individually shaped polyethylene-reinforced dowel (Ribbond) showed the least overall leakage.
Clinical Research
A Simple Method of Preventing Hypersensitivity in Contra-lateral Teeth During Restorative Procedures
Introduction:
Dentin hypersensitivity is a common condition, particularly in patients with gingival recession.1 Restoring anterior teeth in these patients might involve bilateral anterior segment isolation from the premolar/canine to the contra-lateral teeth, but only with unilateral block anesthesia. Although unilateral isolation would help to reduce exposure to thermal stimuli, it also reduces the improved access bilateral isolation provides. Oftentimes, clinicians only find out that contra-lateral teeth are sensitive after rubber dam isolation and starting the restorative procedure. Air from high speed handpieces, high speed vacuum suction and/or water irrigation will illicit a painful response from the side that is not anesthetized. Such a response often makes the patient uncomfortable and delays the restorative procedure. One solution is to anesthetize both sides of the mandible or maxilla. However, anesthesia carries additional inherent risks and time delays.
Introduction:
"Minimally invasive dentistry" has been defined as the maximal preservation of healthy dental tissues. This statement should not be limited to the restorations' extent and size, but it should include assessment of strength of the remaining tooth. It must be kept in mind that any removal of tooth tissue will weaken the tooth and should be avoided in order to optimally preserve the tooth.
Within cariology, "minimally invasive dentistry" includes everything from the correct diagnosis of primary and secondary caries lesions, the assessment of caries risk, caries prevention and the evaluation of caries progression, as well as the repair of restorations as an alternative to their replacement. These case reports focus on the differentiation of stained dental tissues and caries lesions
Guest Editorial
Why Gold Castings Are Excellent Restorations
Tucker Clinical Technique
The Rationale for the Vented-crown Technique and Its Application in Today’s Dental Practice
Clinical Research
Validation and Reliability of Visual Assessment with a Shade Guide for Tooth-Color Classification
Clinical Relevance:
The results of this study showed that the visual assessment of tooth color using the Vitapan Classical shade guide is a valid method for distinguishing between light and dark tooth colors.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the validity and reliability of the visual assessment of tooth color using a commercial shade guide. Ninety-two individuals were randomly selected from subjects enrolled in a randomized controlled trial comparing two formulations of carbamide peroxide. Initially, each individual had the color of his or her six maxillary anterior teeth (n=552) determined by one examiner using a digital spectrophotometer (Vita Easyshade). Then, a visual assessment was made by two calibrated examiners using a shade guide (Vitapan Classical). Reliability was evaluated either by kappa coefficient when all the colors were grouped into two categories (dark and light) or by weighted kappa when all 16 colors of the shade guide were considered. The digital spectrophotometer (Vita Easyshade) was used as the gold standard to calculate sensitivity and specificity of the visual assessment. The reliability of the visual assessment using two color categories was “substantial” (k=0.69). When all colors of the shade guide were considered, the reliability was “mild” (kw=0.33). Sensitivity and specificity of the visual assessment with respect to the gold standard was 86.9% and 81.9%, respectively. Despite its subjectivity, visual assessment of tooth color using the Vitapan Classical shade guide is a valid method, with good reliability for differentiating between dark and light colors.
Clinical Relevance:
This in vivo study supports the hypothesis that the use of in-office bleaching agents is a safe and reliable procedure, inducing no structural damage to the enamel surface, even after prolonged and repeated applications.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the morphological effects produced in vivo by two in-office bleaching agents on enamel surface roughness using a non-contact profilometric analysis of epoxy replicas. The null hypothesis tested was that there would be no difference in the micromorphology of the enamel surface during or after bleaching with two different bleaching agents. Eighteen subjects were selected and randomly assigned to two treatment groups (n=9). The tooth whitening materials tested were 38% hydrogen peroxide (HP) (Opalescence Xtra Boost) and 35% carbamide peroxide (CP) (Rembrandt Quik Start). The bleaching agents were applied in accordance with manufacturer protocols. The treatments were repeated four times at one-week intervals. High precision impressions of the upper right incisor were taken at baseline as the control (CTRL) and after each bleaching treatment (T0: first application, T1: second application at one week, T2: third application at two weeks and T3: fourth application at three weeks). Epoxy resin replicas were poured from impressions, and the surface roughness was analyzed by means of a non-contact profilometer (Talysurf CLI 1000). Epoxy replicas were then observed using SEM. All data were statistically analyzed using ANOVA and differences were determined with a t-test. No significant differences in surface roughness were found on enamel replicas using either 38% hydrogen peroxide or 35% carbamide peroxide in vivo. This in vivo study supports the null hypothesis that two in-office bleaching agents, with either a high concentration of hydrogen or carbamide peroxide, do not alter enamel surface roughness, even after multiple applications.
Laboratory Research
The Effect of Occlusal Loading on the Microleakage of Class V Restorations
Clinical Relevance:
The occlusal stress generated in the cervical region during normal function and parafunction may increase microleakage or detoriate the margins of Class V restorations. This study suggests that self-etch adhesives achieve marginal sealing equal to total-etch adhesives under occlusal loading.
SUMMARY:
Objective: This in vitro study evaluated the microleakage of Class V cavities restored with a resin composite and different adhesive systems after occlusal loading.
Methods & Materials: Standardized box-shaped Class V cavities were prepared on the buccal side of 135 non-carious human premolars. The teeth were randomly divided into three groups of 45 premolars each and restored as follows: Group 1–two-step total-etch adhesive (Single Bond, 3M) + resin composite (Supreme, 3M ESPE); Group 2–two-step self-etch adhesive (Clearfil SE, Kuraray) + resin composite and Group 3-one-step self-etch adhesive (Xeno III, Dentsply) + resin composite. The restorations were finished with aluminum oxide discs (Sof-Lex, 3M). Fifteen teeth in each group received 10,000 x 100 N and 250 N occlusal loads, respectively, and the remaining 15 teeth served as the control. The premolars were immersed in 2% methylene blue for 24 hours. The dye penetration was examined under a stereo-microscope, and the results were statistically analyzed by Kruskal Wallis, Mann-Whitney U and Wilcoxon Signed Rank tests to determine differences between the groups.
Results: Gingival margins showed more dye penetration than occlusal margins in all the tested groups (p<0.05). In all the tested adhesive systems, 100 N occlusal loading did not change dye penetration; however, Groups 1 and 2 exhibited better marginal sealing than Group 3 at the enamel margins under 250 N occlusal loading.
Conclusion: Within the limitations of this in vitro study, it may be concluded that enamel margins provided better marginal sealing than dentin/cementum margins and the two-step self-etch adhesive exhibited better marginal sealing than an all-in-one adhesive at the enamel margins under 250 N occlusal loading.
Clinical Relevance:
The topical application of an antibacterial agent may have the potential to decrease the severity of existing root caries lesions or prevent the development of new lesions.
SUMMARY:
The antimicrobial and anticariogenic properties of a copper varnish (experimental mixture of Doc’s Best Red Copper cement and Copalite varnish, Cooley and Cooley, Ltd, Houston, TX, USA: designated in this study as “Copper Seal”) on the root surface were evaluated in an in vitro microbial caries model. Fifty-six human root specimens were prepared from anterior teeth and randomly divided into four groups: Groups 1 and 3—Copper Seal; Group 2—chlorhexidine varnish, the positive control (Cervitec, Ivolcar Vivadent, Schaan, Liechtenstein) and Group 4—a negative control that received no treatment. The varnishes were painted in Groups 1, 2 and 3, then visually removed after 24 hours in Group 1. The specimens were demineralized in a microbial caries model for five days. Plaque was collected from the specimens to obtain bacterial colonization numbers, then the specimens were sectioned and analyzed for lesion extent using Confocal Laser Scanning microscopy. There were no significant differences (p>0.05) among the four groups in terms of bacterial count. Regarding caries lesion development, the group with copper varnish visually removed (Group 1) and the non-treated group (Group 4) had significantly greater total area caries lesions and total lesion fluorescence than the copper varnish without removal group (Group 3) and the chlorhexidine group (Group 2). Therefore, it was concluded that copper and chlorhexidine varnishes have anticariogenic effects on root surfaces, as tested in this model.
Clinical Relevance:
Since methods of solvent evaporation can change the degree of conversion for some adhesives, practitioners should be aware of the type and composition of bonding agents used.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effect of four methods of solvent evaporation on the degree of conversion (DC) of seven one-bottle adhesive systems: Excite (EX), ONE-STEP (OS), Optibond Solo Plus (OB), Prime&Bond 2.1 (PB), Prime&Bond NT (NT), Single Bond (SB) and Single Bond Plus (SP) using Fourier Transform Infrared Analysis (FTIR). Adhesive resins were: 1) applied to KBr pellet surfaces and left undisturbed for 30 seconds (condition 1), 2) left undisturbed for 30 seconds and air-dried with an air stream for 10 seconds (condition 2), 3) left undisturbed for 60 seconds (condition 3) and 4) left undisturbed for 60 seconds and air-dried for 10 seconds (condition 4) before curing. FTIR spectra were obtained and the DC was calculated by comparing the ratio of aliphatic/aromatic double carbon bonds before and after light-activation for 10 seconds (XL 3000, 3M). The results of each product were analyzed by one-way repeated measure ANOVA and post-hoc Tukey’s test (p<0.05). The DC of PB, NT, OB and SP adhesives was not affected by the four evaporation conditions, while the DC of EX, OS and SB changed according to the evaporation method. The results suggested that the DC of some adhesives was similar regardless of the evaporation method when no water from dentin or rinsing was involved. Other bonding agents showed higher DC after specific conditions of solvent evaporation.
Shear Bond Strength of Self-etch Adhesives to Enamel with Additional Phosphoric Acid Etching
Clinical Relevance:
When using self-etch adhesives to bond composite materials to enamel, there is concern about the ability to achieve bond strengths comparable to approved etch-and-rinse systems. An additional phosphoric acid etching can improve the shear bond strength of self-etch adhesives to enamel.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the shear bond strength of self-etch adhesives to enamel and the effect of additional phosphoric acid etching.
Seventy sound human molars were randomly divided into three test groups and one control group. The enamel surfaces of the control group (n=10) were treated with Syntac Classic (SC). Each test group was subdivided into two groups (each n=10). In half of each test group, ground enamel surfaces were coated with the self-etch adhesives AdheSe (ADH), Xeno III (XE) or Futurabond NR (FNR). In the remaining half of each test group, an additional phosphoric acid etching of the enamel surface was performed prior to applying the adhesives. The shear bond strength was measured with a universal testing machine at a crosshead speed of 1 mm/minute after storing the samples in distilled water at 37°C for 24 hours. Fracture modes were determined by SEM examination. For statistical analysis, one-way ANOVA and the two-sided Dunnett Test were used (p>0.05).
Additional phosphoric etching significantly increased the shear bond strength of all the examined self-etch adhesives (p<0.001). The highest shear bond strength was found for FNR after phosphoric acid etching. Without phosphoric acid etching, only FNR showed no significant differences compared to the control (SC).
SEM evaluations showed mostly adhesive fractures. For all the self-etch adhesives, a slight increase in mixed fractures occurred after conditioning with phosphoric acid.
An additional phosphoric acid etching of enamel should be considered when using self-etch adhesives. More clinical studies are needed to evaluate the long-term success of the examined adhesives.
Clinical Relevance:
New resin composite technologies, such as nano-filled-based systems, have been developed. The assessment of such materials in a simulated laboratory chewing condition may assist with the selection of composites in a clinical situation.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effect of cyclic loading on the bond strength of Class II restorations using different composite materials. Class II preparations with gingival margins located in dentin were performed on the mesial surface of 80 bovine incisors. The teeth were randomly allocated to eight groups (n=10) according to resin composite (Filtek Z250, Filtek Supreme, Tetric Ceram HB and Esthet-X) and use of cyclic loading. The restorations were bonded with the Single Bond adhesive system. Simulated aging groups were cyclic loaded for 200,000 cycles with 80N load (2Hz). The specimens were vertically sectioned (two slabs per restoration) and further trimmed into an hourglass shape at the adhesive interface to obtain a final bonded area 1 mm2. Samples were placed in an apparatus and tested under tension using a universal testing machine. The data were analyzed using two-way ANOVA and Tukey test with a 95% confidence level. Aged groups presented significantly lower means when compared to the groups that were not aged (p=0.03). However, significant differences among composite materials were not observed (p=0.17). Regardless of the restorative composite material used, it could be concluded that the bond strength of Class II restorations at the gingival wall was affected by simulated cyclic loading.
Clinical Relevance:
The results of this study suggest that immediate polishing procedures can result in improved short-term surface smoothness results but do not influence smoothness or sealing ability after one-year storage.
SUMMARY:
Since there is a lack of information on the surface properties of composite restorations achieved with standard polishing procedures after aging processes, this study evaluated the effects of immediate (IM) and delayed (DE) polishing on the surface roughness (Ra), microhardness (KHN) and microleakage (ML) of microfilled (Filtek A110) and hybrid (Filtek Z250) resin composites after one-year storage. Standardized preparations were made on the buccal surface of 256 bovine teeth, where half were restored with each composite. For each composite, the specimens were randomly allocated to two subgroups. The first group (IM) was polished immediately after gross finishing using three different systems/techniques (n=16): Sof-Lex, Flexicups and Flexicups + Jiffy Polishing Brush + Flexibuffs (sequential), then stored for three weeks in saline. The DE group was stored for two weeks, polished with the same systems and stored for one week. From each subgroup, eight specimens were assessed after three weeks regarding Ra, KHN and ML (baseline), and the eight remaining specimens were stored for one year before analysis. The data were analyzed (a=0.05) with ANOVA, paired Student’s t-test (Ra and KHN) or Kruskal-Wallis and Signed Rank tests (microleakage). After one year, microfilled resin composite specimens showed the lowest Ra and KHN (p<0.05). No difference in microleakage was observed among the different groups (p>0.05). The sequential technique provided the lowest roughness and Sof-Lex the lowest hardness (p<0.05). IM showed similar or better performance than DE for ML and Ra (p<0.05). In conclusion, aging increased the composites Ra and ML in all experimental conditions (p<0.05)
Wear Simulation of Resin Composites and the Relationship to Clinical Wear
Clinical Relevance:
Laboratory wear simulation may be useful for estimating the relative clinical wear rates of new resin composite materials.
SUMMARY:
This study used a new generalized wear model to examine the relationship between wear simulation and the clinical wear of two resin composites. Ten specimens each of P50 and Z100, were subjected to 100,000, 400,000 and 800,000 cycles in a spring-loaded piston-type wear simulator. Wear was generated using flat, cylindrically-shaped stainless steel antagonists on the resin composites, which were placed in custom stainless steel fixtures. A slurry of polymethyl methacrylate beads was used as the abrasive media. Wear was determined using profilometry, and the parameters examined included volume loss (mm3), maximum depth (µm), mean maximum depth (µm) and mean depth (µm). Statistical analysis of the laboratory wear data using ANOVA and Tukey’s post hoc test showed a significant difference (p<0.05) for wear between the two materials and the number of cycles. Mean maximum wear (µm) values (100K—P50—11.5 ± 1.8; Z100—4.9 ± 1.0; 400K—P50—17.2 ± 2.7; Z100—6.0 ± 1.7; 800K—P50—20.5 ± 4.6; Z100—9.6 ± 2.5) were used for comparisons with clinical data. Previous clinical studies of P50 and Z100 were used to examine the relationship between laboratory and clinical wear. Linear regression analysis was used to predict laboratory and clinical wear rates. The laboratory wear rate for P50 was 1.3 µm/100K cycles and the rate for Z100 was 0.7 µm/100K cycles. The clinical wear rates for P50 and Z100 were 8.3 µm/year and 4.0 µm/year, respectively. The ratio of wear rates of P50 to Z100 for wear simulation was 1.9 and the ratio of P50 to Z100 for clinical rates was 2.1. These ratios showed good agreement between the relative wear rates of laboratory and clinical wear. For the two composite materials examined, this new simulation model appears to be effective for evaluating the relative wear of resin composites.
Effect of Chlorhexidine Application on Microtensile Bond Strength to Dentin
Clinical Relevance:
Based on the results of this study, the application of chlorhexidine solution at a concentration of 0.12 and 2% before, after or associated with phosphoric acid etching, presented similar behavior with no adverse effect on 24-hour bond strength.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effect on microtensile bond strength (µTBS) of chlorhexidine application to dentin at different times during an indirect restoration luting procedure. Sixty bovine incisors had their superficial dentin subjected to 0.12% and 2% chlorhexidine solutions for 15 seconds before, during and after 37% phosphoric acid etching, resulting in six groups (n=10): 1) 0.12% chlorhexidine + etching; 2) 2% chlorhexidine + etching; 3) etching + 0.12% chlorhexidine; 4) etching + 2% chlorhexidine; 5) etching with 2% chlorhexidine; 6) etching without chlorhexidine (control). An adhesive system (Adper Single Bond 2) was applied and an indirect resin composite restoration (Filtek Z250) was luted using dual cured resin cement (Rely X ARC). After 24 hours of water storage, the specimens were tested by microtensile bond test (µTBS) at 0.5 mm/minute in a universal testing machine. The data were analyzed by one-way ANOVA (a=0.05), demonstrating no significant differences among the groups. The µTBS values in MPa were: 6: 22.83±3.53; 5: 22.4±3.52; 2: 21.62±2.5; 1: 21.28±3.17; 3: 19.62±2.05; 4: 19.55±2.34. The use of chlorhexidine at concentrations of 0.12% and 2% before, after or associated with acid etching did not significantly affect the µTBS values to dentin.
Clinical Relevance:
Fluorescence is one of the optical properties of resin composites and dental tissues that is of great interest today. The fluorescence intensity of restorative materials should be as close as possible to that of human enamel and dentin to ensure an acceptable reproduction of these qualities in esthetic restorations.
SUMMARY:
This study quantitatively evaluated the fluorescence intensity of resin composites with different opacities and translucencies and determined changes in fluorescence after accelerated aging, using human enamel and dentin as controls. Six microhybrid and nanofilled composites, each in three different shades, were tested. Ten sound human incisors were used to obtain enamel and dentin specimens separately. Fluorescence measurements were obtained with a fluorescence spectrophotometer before (baseline) and after accelerated aging at 150 kJ energy for 120 hours. One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Games-Howell multiple comparison tests were performed at a significance level of 0.05. Student’s t-test was also used for comparison before and after aging. At baseline, there was no statistically significant difference (p>0.05) between the fluorescence intensity of dentin and any of the shades of Charisma or Opallis, Esthet-X dentin shade or Vit-l-escence enamel, or the translucent shades. After accelerated aging, all shades of the 4 Seasons, enamel and the translucent shades of Esthet-X had fluorescence intensities statistically similar to that of aged dentin (p>0.05). A significant reduction in fluorescence after aging (p<0.05) was observed for all the materials, except for human enamel and translucent Filtek Supreme XT. Accelerated aging reduced fluorescence in most of the composites evaluated.
Class I Gap-formation in Highly-viscous Glass-ionomer Restorations: Delayed vs Immediate Polishing
Clinical Relevance:
Delaying polishing for one day resulted in improved gap-formation for Class I restoration of highly-viscous conventional and conventional glass-ionomer cements.
SUMMARY:
This in vitro study evaluated the effects of delayed versus immediate polishing to permit maturation of interfacial gap-formation around highly viscous conventional glass-ionomer cement (HV-GIC) in Class I restorations, together with determining the associated mechanical properties. Cavity preparations were made on the occlusal surfaces of premolars. Three HV-GICs (Fuji IX GP, GlasIonomer FX-II and Ketac Molar) and one conventional glass-ionomer cement (C-GIC, Fuji II, as a control) were studied, with specimen subgroups (n=10) for each property measured. After polishing, either immediately (six minutes) after setting or after 24 hours storage, the restored teeth were sectioned in a mesio-distal direction through the center of the model Class I restorations. The presence or absence of interfacial-gaps was measured at 1000x magnification at 14 points (each 0.5-mm apart) along the cavity restoration interface (n=10; total points measured per group = 140). Marginal gaps were similarly measured in Teflon molds as swelling data, together with shear-bond-strength to enamel and dentin, flexural strength and moduli. For three HV-GICs and one C-GIC, significant differences (p<0.05) in gap-incidence were observed between polishing immediately and after one-day storage. In the former case, 80-100 gaps were found. In the latter case, only 9-21 gaps were observed. For all materials, their shear-bond-strengths, flexural strength and moduli increased significantly after 24-hour storage.
Clinical Relevance:
The different types of restorative materials tested were not able to protect adjacent enamel from erosion. Thus, the ability of a restorative material to prevent tooth erosion should not be considered when choosing a material.
SUMMARY:
This in vitro study evaluated the effect of erosive pH cycling on the percentage of surface microhardness change (%SMHC) and wear of different restorative materials and bovine enamel restored with these materials. Eighty enamel specimens were randomly divided into eight groups according to the restorative materials and immersion media used: GI/GV—resin-modified glass-ionomer, GII/GVI—conventional glass-ionomer, GIII/GVII—resin composite and GIV/GVIII—amalgam. Over a period of seven days, groups GI to GIV were immersed in a cola drink (ERO) for 5 minutes, 3x/day and kept in artificial saliva between erosive cycles. Groups GV to GVIII were immersed in artificial saliva (SAL) throughout the entire experimental period (control). Data were tested for significant differences using ANOVA and Tukey’s tests (p<0.05). For %SMHC, considering the restorative materials, no significant differences were detected among the materials and immersion media. Mean wear was higher for the resin modified glass ionomer cement when compared to conventional cement, but those materials did not significantly differ from the others. For enamel analyses, erosive pH cycling promoted higher wear and %SMHC compared to saliva. There were no significant differences in wear and %SMHC of enamel around the different restorative materials, regardless of the distance from the restorative material (50, 150 or 300 µm). In conclusion, there were only subtle differences among the materials, and these differences were not able to protect the surrounding enamel from erosion.
Clinical Technique/Case Report
Clinical Relevance:
The proper utilization of fiber-reinforced resin composite restorations in endodontically-treated molars may preclude the use of more extensive restorative treatment, possibly delaying the need for expensive indirect restorations.
SUMMARY:
The reconstruction of structurally compromised non-vital posterior teeth may represent one of the most challenging adhesive-based restorative procedures. Several factors may influence the longevity of direct fiber-reinforced resin composite restorations: endodontic procedures prior to post cementation, dentin and/or post surface treatments, selection of the appropriate post design and architecture, resin composite polymerization and layering techniques. Thus, different specialties, such as endodontics and restorative dentistry, should work as a team to improve the longevity of restorations. This article presents three-year clinical results following reconstruction of a severely damaged endodontically-treated molar using direct fiber reinforced resin composite systems.
Buonocore Memorial Lecture
Operative Dentistry and the Abuse of Dental Hard Tissues: Confocal Microscopical Imaging of Cutting
SUMMARY:
We reviewed studies wherein the cutting of dental tissues, simulating interactions that would occur under clinical circumstances in the mouth, have been observed directly–first by real time, video rate, stereoscopic, three-dimen-sional scanning electron microscopy; and second and more conveniently, by video rate confocal optical microscopy. We have observed, directly, both the interactions of slow-moving cutting instruments emulating “chisels” and high-speed events, including the effects of rotary burs and air-propelled abrasive particles and soft powder slurries. The observational data contribute to our basic understanding of the functional behavior of dental tissues and formed a useful background for the practitioner of operative dentistry.
Awards
Academy of Operative Dentistry Award of Excellence
Dr William A Gregory
Academy of Operative Dentistry
Hollenback Memorial Prize
Dr Mathilde “Tilly” Peters
American Academy of Gold Foil Operators
Distinguished Member Award
American Academy of Gold Foil Operators
Clinician of the Year Award
Dr Mark Cruz
Book Review
Preservation and Restoration of Tooth Structure, 2nd Edition, 2005
Reviewed by: Mathilde C Peters, DMD, PhD
Guest Editorial
"Oh, John... Nobody does foil anymore."
Academy History
Mat Gold- Gold Foil Restoration
Introduction:
During the past several years, the use of cohesive golds gradually has been increasing in the daily practice of dentistry. It is difficult to determine the motivating influence that has created the increase in interest in this type of restorative service. Perhaps some of the credit can be attributed to the research responsible for the development of new materials, the perfection of clinical techniques which have improved manipulative procedures and the ever-constant influence of the American Academy of Gold Foil Operators, which continually has been emphasizing the need for higher levels of operative services.
The purpose of this presentation is not to delve into all forms of cohesive golds, but primarily to discuss mat gold and its relationship to total restorative services. Mat gold is only one of the many types of cohesive golds available to the profession today. Each of these golds possesses certain qualities and properties which are suitable for specific restorative procedures.
Buonocore Memorial Lecture
Placing Dental Composites-A Stressful Experience
Clinical Relevance:
The inevitable generation of stress in dental composites that undergo polymerization shrinkage continues to mandate a precise and careful placement technique to ensure successful clinical outcomes.
SUMMARY:
The setting of dental composites is accompanied by significant polymerization contraction, resulting in the generation of stresses within the material and at the tooth-restoration interface. These stresses can have a deleterious effect on marginal integrity if they exceed the adhesive strength of the restorative, as well as on the properties of the composite. It has been determined that several factors affect these stresses, including the polymerization rate of the composite, its formulation, including filler and monomer composition and the constraints imposed by the geometry of the cavity preparation. Many strategies have been developed to reduce the effect of these stresses. Changes in the formulation of the composite have included experimentation with a variety of stress relieving additives, modified catalyst compositions and alternative monomer systems. Modifications to the placement techniques have included the use of incremental curing, altered light activation schemes and resilient liners. This manuscript will review many of the important scientific and clinical issues relating to the generation and quantitation of the stresses produced in dental composites during curing.
Clinical Research
Increasing the Longevity of Restorations by Minimal Intervention: A Two-year Clinical Trial
Clinical Relevance:
Treating defective restorations with sealants, repair or refurbishing is an effective way to preserve and treat existing restorations.
SUMMARY:
This investigation assessed the effectiveness of alternative treatments for the replacement of amalgam and resin-based composite restorations. Sixty-six patients (age 18 to 80 years, mean=26.6) with 271 (amalgam [n=193] and resin-based composite [n=78]) defective restorations were randomly assigned to one of five different treatment groups: A) Repair (n=27); B) Sealing of margins (n=48); C) Refurbishing (n=73); D) Replacement (n=42) and E) Untreated (n=81). USPHS/Ryge criteria were used to determine the quality of the restorations. Two calibrated examiners (Cohen's Kappa 0.74) assessed the restorations independently at the beginning of the study (baseline) and at two years after treatment using seven parameters from the USPHS/Ryge criteria (Marginal Adaptation, Anatomic Form, Roughness, Marginal Stain, Occlusal Contact, Secondary Caries and Luster). Results: Two-hundred and fifty-six restorations (178 amalgam and 78 resin-based composite) were examined at the two-year recall exam. The sealing of marginal defects showed significant improvements in marginal adaptation (p<0.05). Refurbishing of the defective restorations significantly improved anatomic form (p<0.0001), luster (p<0.016), marginal adaptation (p<0.003) and roughness (p<0.0001). The repair significantly improved anatomic form (p<0.002) and marginal stain (p<0.002). Replacement showed significant improvements for all parameters (p<0.05). The Untreated group showed significant deterioration on marginal adaptation (p<0.013). Conclusions: The two-year recall examination showed that sealant, repair and refurbishing treatments improved the clinical properties of defective amalgam and resin-based composite restorations by increasing the longevity of the restorations with minimal intervention.
Clinical Relevance:
Class I and II composite restorations placed with a Soft-Start technique showed no significant changes in post-op sensitivity to cold or any decreased signs of marginal stress.
SUMMARY:
The polymerization shrinkage of resin composites may affect restoration quality. A double blind, randomized clinical trial was carried out to compare two curing techniques-Soft-Start (SS) and the plasma arc curing light (PAC). The hypothesis that, delaying the gel point (with SS) improves marginal seal, was tested at alpha=0.05. Also, this report includes two-week, three-month, one-year and two-year results for post-op sensitivity. Twenty informed participants, each needing two Class II and/or complex Class I restorations, gave written consent. All the teeth were trans-illuminated to rule out pre-op crack lines before restoration placement. Fifty Z100-Single Bond restorations (25/SS and 25/PAC) were placed under rubber dam. Protocols: PAC (Control)-incremental curing <2.0 mm, 2000 mW/cm2 for 10 seconds for all layers, SS (Treatment)-incremental curing <2.0 mm, 600 mW/cm2 for 20 seconds, except the final layer or enamel replacement increment, which was cured as follows-(mW/cm2/time) 200/3 seconds, wait 3 minutes; 200/3 seconds, wait 5 minutes; 600/20 seconds from multiple angles.
Sensitivity to a standardized cold stimulus was performed preoperatively at 2 weeks and at 3, 12 and 24 months. Patients rated their sensitivity after stimulus by means of a Visual Analog Scale (VAS). In addition, two independent, calibrated investigators evaluated the restorations clinically at each appointment. There were no significant differences in VAS scores between the two groups at any appointment period (two-way ANOVA; p>0.05).
Several conditions were defined as indicating marginal stress before the start of the trial. At 24 months, there was no significant difference between the SS and PAC groups.
Conclusion: Within the limitations of this study, Class I and II restorations placed with a SS technique did not show significant changes in post-op sensitivity or decreased signs of marginal stress.
Laboratory Research
The Influence of Temperature of Three Adhesive Systems on Bonding to Ground Enamel
Clinical Relevance:
The temperature of adhesive systems must be considered an important factor for the good clinical performance of bonding procedures.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the microtensile bond strength test (µT), micromorphology of resin-enamel interface (RET) and etching patterns (EP) promoted by the etch-and-rinse adhesive, Prime&Bond NT (PB), and two self-etching adhesives, Clearfil SE Bond (SE) and Adper Prompt L-Pop (APR), to ground bovine enamel surfaces, when applied at temperatures of 5°C (C), 40°C (H) and 20°C (R). Materials and Methods. Sixty-three bovine incisors were randomly divided into nine experimental groups (n=7) according to adhesive systems and temperatures. The buccal enamel surfaces were flattened with 600-grit SiC paper and abraded with a diamond bur under water-cooling. The adhesive systems were applied according to the manufacturer’s instructions. After the restorative procedures, the specimens were sectioned into five slabs. Four slabs were prepared for µT and one for interface analysis. For etching pattern analysis, the remaining 16 bovine enamel fragments were used (n=2). The adhesives were applied and the surfaces were rinsed with organic solvents after application. The specimens for RET and EP analysis were prepared for SEM analysis. Results. No significant differences among the adhesives were found at R temperature. However, at 5°C, PB and APR presented lower bond strength than SE. At H temperature, higher bond strength was observed for PB than for APR and SE. At C and H temperature, formation of the interdiffusion zone was impaired and the treated enamel surfaces presented an undefined EP.
Conclusion: The variation of temperature of bonding agents affected µT, RET and EP for all materials tested.
Clinical Relevance:
For the materials tested, there was no difference in adhesion to young and aged tooth structure.
SUMMARY:
In this study, the microtensile bond strengths of an etch-and-rinse resin adhesive to dentin and enamel and a resin-modified glass ionomer adhesive to dentin were determined on teeth known to have originated from subjects over 60 years of age. The same tests were repeated on teeth originating from young subjects. The resin adhesive was Prime & Bond NT (Caulk/Dentsply), while the resin-modified glass ionomer adhesive was Fuji Bond LC (GC America). Both were paired with the same hybrid resin composite, TPH3 (Caulk/Dentsply). Testing was performed after 48 hours using a "non-trimming" microtensile test at a crosshead speed of 0.6 mm/minute. No significant differences were observed between the young and aged teeth for any comparison (p>0.05). SEM evaluation of the etched dentinal surfaces demonstrated less depth of decalcification in the intertubular areas of aged dentin, but there was no observable difference within the tubules of young and aged dentin.
Clinical Relevance:
The nanofilled composite presented a lower degree of conversion, flexural modulus and flexural strength than the hybrid composite. On the other hand, the two materials had a similar hardness. The light polymerization mode influenced only the degree of conversion and the hardness of composites.
SUMMARY:
This study analyzed the influence of the light polymerization mode on the degree of conversion (DC) and mechanical properties of two resin composites: a hybrid (Filtek P60) and a nanofilled composite (Filtek Supreme). The composites were light activated by three light polymerization modes (Standard-S: 650 mW/cm2 for 30 seconds; High intensity-H: 1000 mW/cm2 for 20 seconds and Gradual-G: 100 up to 1000 mW/cm2 for 10 seconds + 1000 mW/cm2 for 10 seconds). The DC(%) was measured by FT-Raman spectroscopy. Flexural strength and flexural modulus were obtained from bar-shaped specimens (1 x 2 x 10 mm) submitted to the three-point bending test. Microhardness was evaluated by Knoop indentation (KHN). Data were analyzed by ANOVA and Student-Newman-Keuls multiple range test and linear regression analysis. The results showed the following DC: H > S > G (p<0.0001) and hybrid > nanofilled (p<0.005). Correlation was found between DC and the radiant exposure (R2 = 0.92). With respect to mechanical properties, only KHN was significantly influenced by the light polymerization mode, as follow: H>S=G (p<0.0001). The hybrid composite presented higher flexural strength and flexural modulus than the nanofilled composite (p<0.0001). No significant difference was found in KHN between the two composites (p=0.1605). The results suggest that nanofilled composites may present a lower degree of conversion and reduced mechanical properties compared to hybrid composites.
SEM Evaluation of the Hybrid Layer After Cavity Preparation with Er:YAG Laser
Clinical Relevance:
The thinner, irregular hybrid layer found when a cavity is prepared with the Er:YAG laser may have a negative effect on bonding.
SUMMARY:
This study compared the thickness of the hybrid layer formed using Scotchbond Multi-Purpose Plus, Single Bond 2, Prime & Bond 2.1 and Xeno III on a dentin surface prepared with a diamond bur in a high speed handpiece or prepared with an Er:YAG laser used with two parameters of pulse energy (200 and 400 mJ) and two parameters of frequency (4 and 6 Hz). Flat dentin surfaces obtained from 20 human third molars were treated with the two methods and were then prepared with the dentin adhesive systems according to the manufacturers' instructions. After a layer of composite was applied, the specimens were sectioned, flattened, polished and prepared for Scanning Electronic Microscopy observation. Five different measurements of the hybrid layer thickness were obtained along the bonded surface in each specimen. The results were statistically analyzed using Analysis of Variance and Student-Newman-Keuls tests (p?0.05). When analyzing the hybrid layer thickness and comparing the cavity preparation method, four groups were formed: Group I (diamond bur) > Group II (Laser 200 mJ/4 Hz) = Group III (Laser 200 mJ/6 Hz) > Group IV (Laser 400 mJ/4 Hz) > Group V (Laser 400 mJ/6 Hz). When comparing the dentin adhesive systems, there were no statistically significant differences. These results showed that the four tested dentin adhesive systems produced a 2.90 ? 1.71 ?m hybrid layer in dentin prepared with a diamond bur. This hybrid layer was regular and routinely found. In the laser groups, the dentin adhesive systems produced hybrid layers ranging from 0.41 ? 1.00 ?m to 2.06 ? 2.49 ?m, which were very irregular and not routinely found. It was also concluded that the Er:YAG laser, with the parameters used in this experiment, has a negative influence on the formation of a hybrid layer and cavity preparation methods influence formation of the hybrid layer.
A Study of the Fracture Resistance of Nyyar Cores of Three Restorative Materials
Clinical Relevance:
The fracture resistance of resin-modified glass ionomer cements merits consideration of their use as core materials for root-filled premolars.
SUMMARY:
Despite the successful use of dental amalgam for coronal-radicular dowel and core build-up in endodontically-treated posterior teeth, newer materials offer many potential advantages over amalgam and have better patient acceptance. This study compared the fracture resistance of coronal-radicular restorations made from three different direct restorative materials. Sixty human premolars were selected, 45 of which were root treated and decoronated. Fifteen of these premolars were restored using amalgam, 15 with composite and 15 using resin-modified glass ionomer. The 15 unrestored teeth were used as a control group. All the teeth were mounted in acrylic within steel containers and subjected to compressive loading to failure on a universal testing machine. The force required to fracture each core specimen was recorded as well as the proportion of core lost due to failure. The results showed dental amalgam as having the highest fracture resistance (mean 1.93kN, sd 0.22) followed by resin-modified glass ionomer (mean 1.05kN, sd 0.20), sound tooth (mean 0.79kN, sd 0.20) and composite (mean 0.75kN, sd 0.11). The differences among all groups were significant. These results demonstrate that, although resin-modified glass ionomer is significantly weaker than amalgam, these restorations were stronger than unrestored teeth and failed at forces in excess of those encountered in normal mastication. Amalgam cores, along with resin-modified glass ionomer, tended to fail less catastrophically than the other materials and, given their strength, would remain the material of choice in situations where abnormally high forces are expected.
Describing Adequacy of Cure with Maximum Hardness Ratios and Non-linear Regression
Clinical Relevance:
Redefined hardness ratios, based on extended cure intervals and maximum hardness when used in conjunction with non-linear regression, provide a readily available and accurate characterization of the curing performance of LCU-composite combinations, which is superior to the use of traditional per-specimen hardness ratios. It is recommended that the light curing guidelines provided to clinicians should be based on this more accurate description of curing behavior.
SUMMARY:
Knoop Hardness (KH) ratios (HR) ? 80% are commonly used as criteria for the adequate cure of a composite. These per-specimen HRs can be misleading, as both numerator and denominator may increase concurrently, prior to reaching an asymptotic, top-surface maximum hardness value (HMAX). Extended cure times were used to establish HMAX and descriptive statistics, and non-linear regression analysis were used to describe the relationship between exposure duration and HR and predict the time required for HR-HMAX = 80%. Composite samples 2.00 x 5.00 mm diameter (n=5/grp) were cured for 10 seconds, 20 seconds, 40 seconds, 60 seconds, 90 seconds, 120 seconds, 180 seconds and 240 seconds in a 2-composite x 2-light curing unit design. A microhybrid (Point 4, P4) or microfill resin (Heliomolar, HM) composite was cured with a QTH or LED light curing unit and then stored in the dark for 24 hours prior to KH testing. Non-linear regression was calculated with: H=(HMAX -c)(1-e-kt) +c, HMAX = maximum hardness (a theoretical asymptotic value), c=constant (t=0), k=rate constant and t=exposure duration describes the relationship between radiant exposure (irradiance x time) and HRs. Exposure durations for HR-HMAX =80% were calculated. Two-sample t-tests for pairwise comparisons evaluated relative performance of the light curing units for similar surface x composite x exposure (10-90s). A good measure of goodness-of-fit of the non-linear regression, r2, ranged from 0.68-0.95. (mean = 0.82). Microhybrid (P4) exposure to achieve HR-HMAX = 80% was 21 seconds for QTH and 34 seconds for the LED light curing unit. Corresponding values for microfill (HM) were 71 and 74 seconds, respectively. P4 HR-HMAX of LED vs QTH was statistically similar for 10 to 40 seconds, while HM HR-HMAX of LED was significantly lower than QTH for 10 to 40 seconds. It was concluded that redefined hardness ratios based on maximum hardness used in conjunction with non-linear regression provides an improved method of evaluating curing performance relative to traditional per-specimen hardness ratios.
Evaluation of Light Transmission Through Translucent and Opaque Posts
Clinical Relevance:
The resin cement polymerization inside the root is decreased, because transmission of light in the apical direction is difficult. This study suggests that the use of translucent posts presents advantages in relation to the opaque posts, however, both do not allow polymerization in the apical region.
SUMMARY:
Objectives: The transmission of light through translucent posts was observed, and the microhardness of light-cured cement used to secure these posts was evaluated at different depths. Methods: Fifteen single-rooted standard bovine teeth, 16 mm in size, were used. The root canals were prepared using #3 drills Light-Post (five teeth) and Aestheti Post (five teeth) systems (BISCO), with a working-length of 12 mm. In five teeth, translucent posts were cemented (Light-Post #2), while another five teeth received opaque posts (Aestheti Post #2). The roots were painted with black nail varnish to prevent the passage of light through the lateral walls of the roots. The root canals of all the specimens were treated with the All-Bond 2 adhesive system (BISCO) and cemented with light-cured cement (Enforce, Dentsply). All the roots were transversally cut to obtain six specimens 1.5 mm thick. Every two sections corresponded to a specific region of the root (cervical, middle, apical), making it possible to observe the cement microhardness at different levels. The groups (n=10) were defined as: G1: translucent post (TP)/cervical region; G2: TP/middle region; G3: TP/apical region; G4: Opaque post (OP)/cervical region; G5: OP/middle region; G6: PO/apical region. Five root canals were only filled with cement for use as a control (G7). Then, Vickers microhardness analyses were performed. Results: In G3, G5 and G6, the cement was not sufficiently hard to allow for microhardness analysis. When submitted to the ANOVA test, G1 (35.07), G2 (24.28) and G4 (28.64) presented no statistical differences. When the previous groups were compared to G7 (51.00) using the Kruskal-Wallis test, a statistical difference was found. Conclusion: Translucent posts allow cement polymerization up to the middle portion of the root.
The Influence of Tip Geometry and Distance on Light-curing Efficacy
Clinical Relevance:
Among the factors that significantly influence the depth of cure of resin composite restorations-the distance between the tip of the light source and the restorative material-as well as the geometry of the tip, are crucial parameters. Increasing the ratio between the entry and exit diameter of the tip will result in an improvement in the depth of cure for lower distances between the tip of the light source and the restorative material, while decreasing the ratio of the depth of cure, which will be higher for greater distances.
SUMMARY:
This study investigated the influence of the light guide shape on the polymerization efficacy of a light-activated resin-based composite cured with LED units as a function of the distance between the tip and the restoration.
Two different LED units, each with different light guides and shapes, were used. Their ability to cure a single restorative material was investigated. The efficacy of the light-curing system was evaluated by measuring the depth of cure using the Acetone Shake test.
Considering the ratio (R) between the entry diameter and the exit diameter of the light guide, the tips with a higher R-value proved to be more efficient if the tip and composite distance (D) was less than 5 mm, while for D>5 mm, the tips with a lower R-value showed better results.
The tip geometry of the tested light guide had a significant influence on the depth of cure of the tested resin composites. Therefore, depending on the distance, the more suitable light guide should be selected, based on the clinical situation. An R-value may be a better descriptor for the light guide shape than words such as "normal" or "turbo."
Esthetic Restorative Materials and Opposing Enamel Wear
Clinical Relevance:
The data obtained in this study can help practitioners with selection of the appropriate restorative materials to minimize further tooth and restoration wear, which is an important consideration during treatment planning.
SUMMARY:
This in vitro study compared the effects of a gold alloy (Degulor M), four dental ceramics (IPS Empress, IPS Empress 2, Duceram Plus, Duceram LFC) and a laboratory-processed composite (Targis) on the wear of human enamel. The amount of wear of the enamel (dental cusps) and restorative materials (disks) were tested in water at 37?C under standard load (20 N), with a chewing rate of 1.3 Hz and was determined after 150,000 and 300,000 cycles. Before the test, the average surface roughness of the restorative materials was analyzed using the Ra parameter. The results of this study indicate that Targis caused enamel wear similar to Degulor M and resulted in significantly less wear than all the ceramics tested. IPS Empress provoked the greatest amount of enamel wear and Degulor M caused less vertical dimension loss. Targis could be an appropriate alternative material to ceramic, because it is esthetic and produces opposing enamel wear comparable to gold alloy.
Clinical Relevance:
The quality of the hybrid layer created in non-carious cervical sclerotic lesions may determine the longevity of cervical composite restorations.
SUMMARY:
This in vitro study observed and compared the resin and non-carious sclerotic dentin interfaces generated by three different adhesives and two different techniques, using a scanning electron microscope (SEM). Thirty-two human premolars, with buccal, non-carious cervical lesions, were used. The teeth were randomly divided into eight groups. Group 1: Sclerotic dentin was treated with Single Bond (3M). Group 2: After superficial sclerotic dentin was removed with a diamond bur (Diatech, Coltene), the dentin surfaces were treated with Single Bond. Group 3: Sclerotic dentin was treated with Clearfil SE Bond (Kuraray). Group 4: After superficial sclerotic dentin was removed with a diamond bur, Clearfil SE Bond was applied. Group 5: Sclerotic dentin was treated with Xeno III (Dentsply). Group 6: After superficial sclerotic dentin was removed with a bur, Xeno III was applied to the dentin surfaces. For Groups 7 and 8, after the superficial sclerotic dentin was removed with a diamond bur, Clearfil SE Bond, with an additional 37% phosphoric acid gel, was used on the sclerotic dentin surfaces in Group 7 and Xeno III was used in Group 8. In all groups, the cavities were restored with Filtek Supreme (3M). All the specimens were sectioned longitudinally and polished along the cut surface. The sections were treated with 37% orthophosphoric acid for five seconds, rinsed with water and treated with 5% NaOCL for 10 minutes. The specimens were then gold-sputter coated and evaluated under SEM. The thickness of the hybrid layer was measured on the gingival, occlusal and axial dentin interfaces. ANOVA was performed to determine whether there were any statistically significant differences in hybrid layer thickness. Post-hoc multiple comparisons were done with Tukey's test. Hybrid layer thickness was increased with all adhesives when superficial dentin was removed with a bur. Hybrid layer thickness showed significant differences between total-etch and self-etch systems.
Literature Review
Surface Treatments for Improving Bond Strength to Prefabricated Fiber Posts: A Literature Review
Clinical Relevance:
Several surface treatments have been proposed for improving the bonding of resin cements or core materials to FRC (fiber-reinforced composite) posts. The possibility of combining chemical and micromechanical retention on post surface provides the most promising adhesion mechanism.
SUMMARY:
This literature review summarizes the research on fiber post surface treatments and provides information related to their benefit in enhancing bond strength to composites, based on the results of original scientific full papers from peer-reviewed journals listed in Pub Med. The search was conducted using the terms "fiber post," "surface treatment," "surface conditioning," "etching" and "sandblasting." A consistent number of in vitro studies that investigated the surface treatment of fiber posts in an attempt to improve bond strength have been published to date. Their results have been summarized in the following categories: chemical treatments and micro-mechanical treatments of fiber post surfaces (or a combination of both principles). The majority of available literature data is based on studies that investigated different "chairside" post superficial treatments. According to the in vitro results, surface conditioning improves fiber post bonding properties, and the bond strength of pre-treated fiber posts to restorative materials is satisfactory. Long-term clinical studies are needed prior to making a general recommendation for their use.
Clinical Technique/Case Report
Modified Matrix Band Design for Ultra-conservative Posterior Restorations
Clinical Relevance:
The combination of minimally invasive cavity preparations and adhesive restorations allows clinicians a significantly more conservative approach to proximal carious lesions of teeth adjacent to MO/DO preparations.
SUMMARY:
Conventional box preparations, tunnel cavities and slot preparations have been recommended for the treatment of proximal carious lesions over the years. If the adjacent tooth is missing or the proximal surface becomes accessible at the time of cavity preparation of the adjacent tooth, a direct proximal access to the decay process can be performed. A similar procedure is supported by the use of adhesive composite restorations reinforcing the remaining sound tooth structure. The increasing patient and clinician's desire for ultraconservative treatment justifies this minimally invasive tooth preparation approach; however, appropriate materials and techniques need to be selected to achieve adequate bonding of the cavity walls and marginal adaptation of the composite.
Guest Editorial
Looking to the Future...and the Future Looks Great!
Tucker Clinical Technique
Introduction:
The treatment for this patient involved the lower left cuspid and first premolar. The premolar was restored with a conventional MOD inlay, while the cuspid was planned as a distal hollow grind preparation with a pin to keep tissue removal and final restoration as conservative as possible. Although the initial caries was extensive, the final restorations were invisible, except when viewed from a distal buccal aspect. While the patient was not so advised, these restorations will likely serve a lifetime with proper maintenance.
Clinical Research
Clinical Relevance:
Lower scores for marginal discoloration and adaptation were noted when an all-in-one self-etching adhesive was applied to non-carious cervical lesions and compared to a three-step total-etch adhesive.
SUMMARY:
This randomized clinical trial compared the performance of an all-in-one adhesive (iBond) applied in sclerotic and non-sclerotic non-carious cervical lesions with that of a three-step etch-prime-bond adhesive (Gluma Solid Bond, SB). One-hundred and five lesions were randomly assigned to four groups according to adhesive, sclerosis scale and technique: 1) SB applied to lesions with sclerosis scale 1 and 2 (n=26); 2) iBond applied to lesions with sclerosis scale 1 and 2 (n=28); 3) iBond applied to lesions with sclerosis scale 3 and 4 (n=25) and 4) iBond applied with prior acid-etching to lesions with sclerosis scale 3 and 4 (n=26). A microfilled composite (Durafill VS) was used as the restorative material. The restorations were evaluated for retention, color match, marginal adaptation, anatomic form, cavosurface margin discoloration, secondary caries, pre- and post-operative sensitivity, surface texture and fracture at insertion (baseline), 6, 18 months and at 3 years using modified USPHS evaluation criteria (Alfa=excellent; Bravo=clinically acceptable; Charlie=clinically unacceptable). There was a high percentage of Bravo scores for marginal adaptation (4%-32%) and marginal discoloration (18%-60%) in Groups 2, 3 and 4, but all groups had <5% Charlie scores at 6 months and <10% Charlie scores at 18 months for retention and marginal discoloration, respectively. However, it should be noted that 13% of the restorations in Group 4 were not retained at three years.
Comparison of Traditional and Low Sensitivity Whiteners
Clinical Relevance:
The results of this double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial have direct relevance to clinical practice and provide evidence that the addition of low levels of potassium nitrate and/or potassium nitrate and fluoride significantly reduce postoperative sensitivity relative to products that do not contain either agent.
SUMMARY:
This placebo-controlled, double-blind randomized clinical trial compared five 10% carbamide peroxide tooth whitening formulations. Three products contained varying concentrations of potassium nitrate as desensitizers. One contained no desensitizers and one was a placebo. During the two weeks of active bleaching, participants used a daily diary to record the number of days of sensitivity from hot, cold, gums, tongue and/or throat. The total number of days of sensitivity experienced by the participants in each group was compared. Participants using the agent with no desensitizers did not experience any more sensitivity than those using the agent containing 3% potassium nitrate. The products that included 0.5% potassium nitrate and 0.5% potassium nitrate and 0.25% sodium fluoride were not associated with any more sensitivity than the placebo group.
In addition, the shade tab change from baseline to 11 weeks following cessation of bleaching was compared. Using an active bleaching agent, no difference in color change was noted among the four groups. All four groups were associated with significantly higher color change than the placebo.
The addition of a small percentage of potassium nitrate to a 10% carbamide peroxide tooth whitener was shown to significantly reduce postoperative sensitivity without reducing efficacy.
Laboratory Research
Influence of Cement Shade and Water Storage on the Final Color of Leucite-reinforced Ceramics
Clinical Relevance:
Luting cement under 0.8 mm thick leucite-reinforced ceramic changed the final color of the ceramic and could be seen by the human eye. Therefore, clinicians may prefer to use try-in pastes or polymerized luting composite shade guides to compensate for the change in color of definitive restorations, such as laminate veneers. The final color differences between ceramics luted with cements in A1 and A3 shades were not clinically perceivable at each measurement. Within the limitations of this study, changing the color of an IPS Empress laminate veneer restoration via the shade of the cement seems not to be a preferred method.
SUMMARY:
Leucite-reinforced ceramics have a translucent structure, which may have an advantage when fabricating esthetic restorations. However, the different shades of cement and water storage may adversely affect the final color of translucent restorations. Over time, the final color of a restoration may be significantly affected by the shade of the cement. This in vitro study evaluated the effect of two different cement shades (Vita A1 and A3) and water storage on the final color of leucite-reinforced ceramics over time. Twenty disks of standardized thickness (0.8 mm), diameter (5 mm) and color (shade 110, Chromascope) were prepared from leucite-reinforced glass-ceramic (IPS Empress). Ten freshly extracted human molars were used as the underlying structure, and both the buccal and lingual surfaces of each tooth were prepared with a diamond rotary cutting instrument and flat surfaces were created. Initially, all of the disks were bonded to the flat surfaces of the teeth with a thin layer of bonding agent (Single Bond, 3M Dental Products) to ensure immobilization of the specimens (baseline). The teeth and ceramic specimens were not etched and silanated for easy removal of the specimens. The color of the ceramic specimens was measured with a colorimeter. All disks were gently removed from the tooth surfaces, and 10 specimens (Group A1) were luted to the buccal surfaces of teeth using a dual-polymerizing resin composite cement (Vita A1, Rely X ARC), while the remaining 10 specimens (Group A3) were luted to the lingual surfaces of the teeth with a different shade (Vita A3, Rely X ARC) of the same cement. The final color of the specimens was measured immediately after cementation and at 3-, 30- and 90-day intervals after cementation. Color coordinates L*, a*, b* were recorded. The teeth were stored in 37?C saline solution during measurement intervals. The Mann-Whitney U-test (post-hoc test) was performed to compare the results (a=0.05). The color difference of specimens luted with the two cements with different shades was not perceivable (DE<3.7) for AC (after cementation), AC/3, AC/30 and AC/90 measurements. The color alteration between baseline and immediately after cementation (AC) was not perceivable for each cement group. However, after water storage, color differences between the baseline and AC/3, AC/30 and AC/90 were above this limit in bo th cement groups. The shade of the luted 0.8 mm IPS Empress porcelain specimens became darker after cementation, particularly on the third day, regardless of the cement shade tested. When the final color of ceramics luted with cements in two different shades was compared, it was observed that the final color differences were not perceivable for each measurement session.
Microleakage of All-ceramic Crowns Using Self-etching Resin Luting Agents
Clinical Relevance:
Among the self-adhesive resin cements, Panavia F 2.0 demonstrated less microleakage than RelyX Unicem or Multilink, whether or not a die spacer technique was used.
SUMMARY:
Self-etching adhesive systems are a new generation of materials that possess acidic methacrylates that can generate self-adhesion. There is limited data reported on the marginal leakage of ceramic restorations bonded with self-etching adhesive materials.
This study assessed and compared the amount of microleakage of bonded ceramic crowns using three different types of self-etching adhesive systems with and without a die spacer.
Eighteen human molars were prepared for all-ceramic IPS Empress crowns and the teeth were randomly assigned to each experimental group. The buccal side had the preparation finish line 1.5 mm below the CEJ, and the lingual finish line was 1.5 mm above the CEJ, creating margins in enamel and dentin. Two die-spacing techniques were used (three layers or no layer of die spacer). Each crown restoration was cemented with one of three self-etching resin luting agents (Panavia F 2.0, Multilink and RelyX Unicem). The specimens were thermally cycled for 1000 cycles, then immersed in a 5% methylene blue dye solution for 24 hours. The teeth were then rinsed, embedded in clear epoxy resin and sectioned. A total of 60 sections were evaluated for each type of resin luting agent using digital image analysis at 70x magnification. A novel formula, using mean percentage of microleakage, was developed by dividing the extent of dye penetration along the tooth/resin luting cement interphase and the total perimeter of the tooth crown surface. The data were analyzed using three-way analysis of variance at the 0.05 level of significance. Fisher's PLSD intervals were calculated for comparing significant means.
Panavia F 2.0 showed a lower degree of microleakage than RelyX Unicem and Multilink at both the enamel and dentin margins. Interactions of the main effects (cement, margin and die spacer technique) were all highly significant (p?0.004). The degree of microleakage was higher on the dentin margins than on the enamel margins (p<0.0001). The degree of microleakage for the die spacer group was not significantly different from the group with no die spacer technique (p>0.1).
Overall, Panavia F 2.0 showed the least microleakage, followed by RelyX Unicem and Multilink, respectively.
Should My New Curing Light Be An LED?
Clinical Relevance:
This study provides information concerning curing light unit purchase decision criteria and supporting evidence to compare various curing light units that are on the market.
SUMMARY:
The new generation LED curing light units have significantly improved curing performance compared to first generation lights, and even some second generation LED curing light units. This study compared the curing performance of 10 new generation LED light curing units (FLASH-lite 1401, LE Demetron 1, Coltolux, Ultra-Lume 5, Mini LED, bluephase, Elipar FreeLight 2, Radii, Smartlite IQ and Allegro) for depth of cure against a high-powered halogen curing light unit (Optilux 501). Depth of cure measurements were utilized per the ANSI/ADA No 27 standard to detect differences between the lights at three time intervals (10, 20 and 40 seconds). A total of 660 samples were prepared (n=10/group). A full factorial ANOVA and Tukey's HSD test showed FLASH-lite 1401 performed significantly better than the other lights at 10- and 20-second time intervals (p<0.01). This study also demonstrated that an exposure time of 20 seconds or longer assures a better depth of cure, 40 seconds being the optimal polymerization time for all of the curing light units.
Clinical Relevance:
Achieving a high degree of cure throughout a 2 mm thickness of light-activated resin composite did not occur for many types and shades of resin composite. Clinicians should check the depth of cure by using the scraping method.
SUMMARY:
The optimal degree of curing throughout the bulk of a visible light-activated dental resin composite is acknowledged to be important to the clinical success of a resin composite restoration. Unfortunately, the dentist has no means of monitoring the cure of the resin surfaces not directly exposed to the curing light. Techniques, such as the layered buildup of restorations in 2 mm increments with longer activation times than 20 seconds, have been suggested. This study investigated the depth of cure (DOC) of a commercial resin composite in three types: flowable, hybrid and packable and in three shades: B1, A3 and D3 after 20 second activation with a quartz halogen light (620 mW/cm2). Depth of cure was measured by scraping the uncured material and by using a Knoop Hardness profile, starting from the surface exposed to the light. Using a minimum Knoop Hardness ratio of 0.8 bottom/top only, the flowable in shade B1 achieved a 2 mm DOC. Using the less restrictive scraping test, only the B1 shade of flowable and hybrid significantly exceeded a 2 mm DOC. Knoop Hardness at the DOC obtained by scraping ranged from 55%-70% of the top surface hardness.
These data suggest that a 2 mm buildup layering technique may not result in adequate curing of the bottom layer for such a wide range of materials and that manufacturers need to provide quantitative information about DOC at specific activation times and light intensities for their entire range of resin materials and shades so that the dentist can devise a placement technique that will ensure adequate cure of the bulk of a restoration.
Color Stability of Nanocomposites Polished with One-Step Systems
Clinical Relevance:
The color stability of nanocomposites depends on the material's properties, rather than the polishing systems used.
SUMMARY:
Objective: This study compared the color changes of five novel resin composites polished with two one-step polishing systems when exposed to coffee solution.
Methods: The resin composites tested were Filtek Supreme XT, Grandio, CeramX, Premise and Tetric EvoCeram. A total of 150 discs (30/resin composites, 10 x 2 mm) were fabricated. Ten specimens/resin composites cured under Mylar strips served as the control. The other samples were polished with PoGo and OptraPol discs for 30 seconds using a slow speed handpiece and immersed in coffee (Nescafe) for seven days. Color measurements were made with Vita Easyshade at baseline and after one and seven days. Repeated Measures ANOVA and Bonferroni tests were used for statistical analyses (p?0.05).
Results: The differences between the mean DE* values for the resin composites polished with two different one-step systems were statistically significant (p<0.05). After one week, all materials exhibited significant color changes compared to baseline. All Mylar finished specimens showed the most intense staining (p<0.05).
There were no significant differences between the OptraPol and PoGo polished groups. Mylar-finished specimens of CeramX, Tetric EvoCeram, Premise and Filtek Supreme XT presented the greatest staining (p<0.05). For Grandio, there were no significant differences between the Mylar and PoGo groups, while the most stain resistant surfaces were attained with OptraPol.
Conclusion: Removing the outermost resin layer by polishing procedures is essential to achieving a stain resistant, more esthetically stable surface. One-step polishing systems can be used successfully for polishing nanocomposites.
Clinical Relevance:
The association of transdental and direct photo-activation of composite restorations might improve marginal adaptation, while not being detrimental to composite hardness.
SUMMARY:
This study investigated the influence of different light sources associated with a transdental photo-activation technique on the marginal adaptation and hardness of composite restorations. Cavities (3 mm wide x 3 mm long x 1.5 mm in deep) were prepared on flattened bovine dentin and filled with Z250 composite (3M ESPE). Nine groups (n=10) were defined according to the curing technique (direct; transdental-photo-activation through 1 mm of enamel and 2 mm of dentin; mixed-transdental + direct) and light source (QTH XL2500, 3M ESPE; PAC Apollo 95E, DMD; LED Ultrablue Is, DMC) combination. Marginal adaptation was evaluated using a dye staining method, and the percentage of stained margins was recorded. Knoop Hardness readings were made across the transversal section of the fillings. Data were submitted to two-way ANOVA and Tukey's test (p?0.05). For margin analysis, although none of the curing conditions provided perfect adaptation, the mixed technique showed lower gap formation. No significant differences were detected between the transdental and other techniques, and no significant differences were detected among the light sources. For hardness, the direct technique showed slightly greater hardness than the mixed technique. Also, the mixed technique yielded greater hardness than the transdental technique. Among the light sources, the LED showed greater hardness than the PAC; whereas, no significant differences between the QTH and other sources were detected. The mixed technique might improve the marginal adaptation of restorations, while not being detrimental to composite hardness.
Effect of Prior Acid Etching on Bonding Durability of Single-Step Adhesives
Clinical Relevance:
The ability of acid etching to increase enamel bond strengths varies among single-step self-etch adhesive systems.
SUMMARY:
This study investigated the effect of prior phosphoric acid etching on the enamel bond strength of five single-step self-etch adhesive systems: Absolute, Clearfil tri-S Bond, Fluoro Bond Shake One, G-Bond and One-Up Bond F Plus. Bovine mandibular incisors were mounted in self-curing resin, and the facial surfaces were wet ground with #600 silicon carbide paper. Adhesives were applied to the enamel surfaces with or without prior phosphoric-acid etching and light irradiated. The resin composites were condensed into a mold and light irradiated. In total, 40 specimens were tested per adhesive system with and without prior acid etching and were further divided into two groups: those stored in water at 37?C for 24 hours without cycling and those stored in water at 37?C for 24 hours followed by thermal cycling between 5?C and 55?C with 10,000 repeats. After storage under each set of conditions, the specimens were tested in shear mode at a crosshead speed of 1.0 mm/minute. Two-way analysis of variance, the Student's t-test and the Tukey HSD test were used to analyze the data at a significance level of 0.05. For the specimens without prior acid etching, the mean bond strengths to enamel ranged from 11.0 to 14.6 MPa after 24-hour storage in water, while the corresponding values for specimens with prior acid etching ranged from 15.2 to 19.3 MPa. When these specimens were subjected to thermal cycling, the mean bond strengths ranged from 11.3 to 17.0 MPa without prior acid etching and from 12.3 to 23.2 MPa with prior acid etching. The changes in enamel bond strengths differed among the adhesive systems tested. After 24-hour storage in water, the mo