Links Of Interest
Journal Authors
Subscribe Reviewers
 
 

CLINICAL RESEARCH

REVIEW SUBMISSION PAGE
E-mail: editor@jopdent.org

Directions: This page will allow you to submit a CLINICAL RESEARCH review. Please complete all the information below, then click "Review your Comments". You will have the opportunity to review your comments prior to e-mailing your comments to the editor. When you e-mail your review to the editor, a copy will be e-mailed to you, at the address you provide below.

Reviewer's name:
Reviewer's e-mail:
Manuscript Title:
Manuscript Number:

After reading the manuscript, please complete these questions and PROVIDE DETAILED SUPPORTING COMMENTS.

  1. Paper falls within the scope of Operative Dentistry:
    Yes  No
  2. Methods and research design are acceptable:
    Yes  No
  3. The experimental sample selection and size are:
    • appropriate
      		•  Yes  No
    • well-controlled
      		•  Yes  No
  4. Statistical treatment:
    • is acceptable
      		•  Yes  No
    • needs statistician review
      		•  Yes  No
  5. Results are:
    • new and original
      		•  Yes  No
    • valuable confirmation
      		•  Yes  No
    • known facts
      		•  Yes  No
  6. Conclusions are consistent with the results:
    Yes  No
  7. The figures and tables:
    are adequate
    should be revised
    should be eliminated
    are not present but would help
    are not present and are not needed
  8. References
    are adequate
    are excessive
    are inadequate/inaccurate
    contain errors
    Are not applicable
  9. Contribution to the knowledge base is:
    major
    medium
    minor
    none
  10. The article should be:
    accepted for publication
    conditionally accepted for publication
    reconsidered after major revisions are completed
    rejected
  11. Reviewer's Comments:
  12. Confidential Comments for the Editor ONLY: